Fact or Opinion?
Building Critical Thinking Skills
Activity Description
Preparation:
-
Prepare task cards for each student
- Cut out small cards from cardstock
- On one side write the word Fact and on the other side write the word Opinion
-
Select a short non-fiction text
- Copy the text onto a piece of chart paper
-
Prepare the Facts and Opinions chart
- Record a definition for a fact and for an opinion on another piece of chart paper
- List examples of each term
Implementation:
Session 1:
-
Read aloud sentences
-
Have students determine whether each sentence is a fact or an opinion
- Students should hold up the task card showing the correct side
- Have students discuss reasons for their decisions
-
Have students determine whether each sentence is a fact or an opinion
Session 2:
-
Read aloud the definitions of a fact and an opinion on the Facts and Opinions chart
- Discuss the list of examples
- Have students share examples of facts and opinions and record their ideas on the chart
- Read aloud your selected text
- Have students identify the sentences that are facts and the sentences that are opinions
a. Use 2 different colors to underline these sentences
Adaptations For
English Language Learners/ESL:
- Provide a symbol or picture to identify the terms "fact" and "opinion"
- Prior to the activity, pre-teach each term and model examples for student
- Pause after each sentence has been shared to allow all students time to respond
LD/Reading & Writing Difficulties:
- Anchor the Facts and Opinions chart on the wall as a reference
- Color code the words and definitions
- Meet with student one-on-one to review terms and examples
Cultural Appropriateness & Diversity:
- Choose a text that is culturally inclusive and familiar
Differentiated Instruction:
- List a variety of examples on the Facts and Opinions chart
Related References
Evidence: Flowers, T. A. & Flowers, L. (2009). Nonfiction in the early grades: Making reading and writing relevant for all students. Journal for the Liberal Arts and Science, 13, 40-50.
Activity Objective
The goal of Fact or Opinion?: Building Critical Thinking Skills is to foster critical thinking skills and to extend students' understanding of texts by explicitly teaching the difference between a fact and an opinion.
What You Need
Prep Time:
20 minutes - Prepare task cards
- Select a short non-fiction text that includes facts and opinions
- Prepare Facts and Opinions chart
Task Time:
20-30 minutes - Teacher reads aloud 8-10 sentences
- Students discuss sentences
- Teacher reads aloud and discusses chart and non-fiction text
- Students discuss sentences in non-fiction text
Materials Required:
Teacher:
- Chart paper
- Markers
- Non-fiction text
- Cardstock
- Scissors
What You Do
Teacher Role:
Facilitator:
- while students discuss sentences and chart
Direct instruction:
- while teacher reads aloud and discusses Facts and Opinions chart
Student Grouping:
Whole class:
- when teacher reads sentences, students discuss sentences, teacher reads non-fiction text and students discuss text
Assessment Ideas:
- Use a checklist to determine students' understanding of facts and opinions after they complete an independent task
Quick Tips
Activity Extensions:
- Give students a new text and have them independently underline the facts and opinions using different colored markers
- On another piece of chart paper record facts and opinions that appear in different texts throughout the year
Additional Comments:
- Emphasize the difference between a fact and an opinion throughout your discussion. Help students understand that a fact can be proven while an opinion is usually someone's feelings about the topic.
- Make sure to select a text that includes a variety of sentences that are both facts and opinions.
- Explicitly teaching the difference between facts and opinions will help students apply their knowledge of these terms while reading.
Other Adaptations/Modifications:
- Strategically seat students who might need cues to refocus