Question Chart
Improving Reading Comprehension through Questioning
Activity Description
Preparation:
1. Assemble a guided reading group
a. Select 4-6 students with similar reading abilities
2. Gather 5-7 copies of a story
a. Ensure there are enough for each student to have their own copy
3. Create an assortment of pre-reading questions
a. Students should be able to extrapolate answers to these questions by looking at the front cover
of the book
b. For example, what do you think the story will be about? Or who do you think the main characters of
the story are?
c. Write each question on a separate cue card
4. Create a question chart
a. The title of this chart can be “I Wonder…” and the headings, Who, What, Where, When Why, and How
should appear across the top of the page
5. Gather materials required by students
a. For example, sticky notes, pencils, mini white boards, and dry erase markers
Implementation:
1. Pose pre-reading question
a. Have students use the text cover for clues and write their responses on mini white boards
2. Invite students to share and justify their responses
3. Introduce the question chart
a. Draw students’ attention to the various question categories and provide sample questions for each
category
4. Invite students to begin reading the first few pages of the story independently and generate questions as they read
a. Have students write each question on a separate sticky note and then stick the sticky note under the
appropriate heading on the question chart
b. For example, questions containing what… should be pasted underneath the what heading
5. Stop students after they have all read the first few pages of the story and invite them to share some of their generated questions
6. Have students continue reading the story independently and encourage them to answer the generated questions
a. Invite students to remove the sticky note and write the
answer below the question or to write the answer on a separate sticky note and stick it onto the
corresponding question on the chart
7. Circulate as students complete the activity and have individual students share and justify their questions and answers
Adaptations For
English Language Learners/ESL:
- Group students who speak the same first language together and encourage them to communicate in their first language to enhance comprehension
- Work with individual students to write and answer questions
LD/Reading & Writing Difficulties:
- Work with individual students to write and answer questions
Cultural Appropriateness & Diversity:
- Select a story with characters that are representative of the student population and that is relevant and meaningful to all students
Differentiated Instruction:
- Ensure story caters to students' interests and reading levels
Related References
Evidence:
Shanahan, T., Callison, K., Carriere, C., Duke, N. K., Pearson, P. D., Schatschneider, C., & Torgesen, J. (2010). Improving Reading Comprehension in Kindergarten through 3rd Grade: A Practice Guide (NCEE 2010-4038). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.
Activity Objective
The goal of Question Chart: Improving Reading Comprehension through Questioning is for students to generate questions about a text and to answer these questions as they engage in independent reading. By generating and responding to these questions, students develop a deeper understanding of the text.
What You Need
Prep Time:
15-20 minutes
- Select students to form guided reading group
- Gather 5-7 copies of the same story
- Generate an assortment of pre-reading questions
- Create a question chart
- Gather materials required for students
Task Time:
20-30 minutes
- Teacher poses pre-reading question
- Students write answers to pre-reading question on mini whiteboards
- Teacher explains how the question chart is to be used
- Students read story, write questions on sticky notes and attach questions under appropriate headings on the question chart
- Teacher reads students' questions aloud
- Students continue to read the story and attempt to answer the questions posed
Materials Required:
Teacher:
- Question chart
- Copy of story
- Assortment of pre-reading questions written on paper or cue cards
Students:
- Mini white board (1 per student)
- Dry erase marker (1 per student)
- Copy of story (1 per student)
- Sticky notes (5 per student)
- Pencils
Optional:
- Before-reading wheel a. Used instead of hand-written pre-reading questions
What You Do
Teacher Role:
Direct instruction:
- while explaining the question chart
Supporter:
while students read and generate, write, and answer questions
Student Grouping:
Small group:
- during question sharing and discussion
Individual:
- during reading, question writing and question answering
Assessment Ideas:
- Save sticky notes and assess the quality of student generated questions and answers a. Ensure that students write their names or initials below their questions and answers for assessment purposes
Quick Tips
Activity Extensions:
- Encourage students to use the question chart during independent reading time
- Invite students to generate questions and have their classmates respond to them
Additional Comments:
- The pre-reading question serves as a nice warm-up to using the question chart a. Encourages students to use the text for clues and gathering information to build comprehension
- Having students generate questions and answers about a text promotes deep processing of the content and thus strengthens comprehension