Before, During and After Questions
Promoting Reading Comprehension and Critical Thinking
Activity Description
Preparation:
-
Gather sticky notes
- One color sticky note should be used for before-reading questions, a different color sticky note should be used for during-reading questions and a third color sticky note should be used for after-reading questions
- For example, use blue sticky notes for all before-reading questions, yellow sticky notes for all during-reading questions and pink sticky notes for all after-reading questions
-
Prepare the Before, During and After Reading question chart
- For example: Developing the heart of the story
- Model the writing strategy by using a short piece of text
- Select a story
Implementation:
-
Explain how the Before, During and After Reading question chart is to be used
-
Describe how students can:
- pose questions about a text prior to reading based on the information on the cover of the book
- ask questions while reading a text and
- generate questions upon reflection, after reading a text
- For example, use blue sticky notes for all before-reading questions, yellow sticky notes for all during-reading questions and pink sticky notes for all after-reading questions
-
Describe how students can:
- Draw students’ attention to their sticky notes and explain which color is to be used for writing before reading questions, which is to be used for the during reading questions and which is to be used for the after reading questions
-
Present students with the front cover of the selected story
- Refer to the mini-lesson and remind students to focus on the selected topic
-
Invite students to generate before reading questions
- Encourage them to share their questions with a partner
-
Have students stick their before reading questions onto the question chart
- Read some examples aloud
-
Begin reading the story aloud
- Invite students to write their during reading questions as the story is read
- Remind students to think deeply about the story so that questions can be generated
-
Pause twice while reading and have students paste their during reading questions onto the question chart
- Read aloud some examples of questions as they are pasted
-
After the story is read, have students identify whether any of the during questions were answered
- Have students share their answers and put a checkmark on sticky notes as the questions are answered
-
Invite students to reflect on the story and generate after reading questions
- These can be some of the unanswered during reading questions
- Have students paste their after reading questions
- Invite students to read some of their after reading questions aloud
Adaptations For
English Language Learners/ESL:
- Have students who speak the same first language work together, especially during the think-pair-share
- Provide key vocabulary from the text to students ahead of time
- Allow students to pictorially represent their questions and invite them to orally share them with the class when they are posted
LD/Reading & Writing Difficulties:
- Allow students to pictorially represent their questions and invite them to orally share them with the class when they are posted
Cultural Appropriateness & Diversity:
- Select a story that is culturally meaningful and relevant that is representative of the student/school community
Differentiated Instruction:
- Encourage students to generate multiple questions
- Invite early finishers to begin reading other students questions and attempt to answer them independently
- Conduct this activity in small groups that are differentiated by reading level
Related References
Evidence:
Shanahan, T., Callison, K., Carriere, C., Duke, N. K., Pearson, P. D., Schatschneider, C., & Torgesen, J. (2010). Improving Reading Comprehension in Kindergarten through 3rd Grade: A Practice Guide (NCEE 2010-4038). Washington, DC: National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education.
Activity Objective
The goal of Before, During and After Questions: Promoting Reading Comprehension and Critical Thinking is for students to generate questions pertaining to a text to encourage deep processing and understanding.
What You Need
Prep Time:
5 minutes
- Gather 3 different colored sticky notes
- Create Before, During and After Reading questioning chart
- Select a story
Task Time:
20-30 minutes
- Teacher introduces Before, During and After Reading question chart
- Students generate before-reading questions and share with a partner
- Teacher reads story aloud as students generate during-reading questions
- Students attempt to answer their during-reading questions and pose after-reading questions
- Students brainstorm potential answers to their after-reading questions
Materials Required:
Teacher:
- Story
- Before, During and After Reading chart
Students:
- Clipboard (1 per student)
- 3 different colored sticky notes (3 of each color per student)
- Pencils
What You Do
Teacher Role:
Direct Instruction:
- while introducing before, during and after reading questioning activity
Modeling:
- when providing examples of before, during, and after reading questions
Facilitator:
- while students generate questions
Student Grouping:
Whole class:
- during the activity introduction, read aloud and question sharing
Pairs:
- during think-pair-share
Individual:
- when students generate before, during and after reading questions
Assessment Ideas:
- Have students put their initials underneath their written questions and assess for quality and depth
Quick Tips
Activity Extensions:
- Invite students to create their own before, during, and after reading question chart and use it during independent reading
- Instead of orally discussing potential answers to after reading questions, have students reflect on these and write potential answers in their journal
a. Remind students to explain their thinking and rationale
- Remind students to explain their thinking and rationale
Additional Comments:
- If some of the student-generated during questions are not answered after the story is read, reassure students that it is OK and attempt to create some potential answers as a class along with other after reading questions
a. Having students create their own answers to questions facilitates deep processing of the text and instills critical thinking skills
- This comprehension strategy can also be used when reading non-fiction texts