Visual Thinking Strategies
Exploring Artwork to Enhance Critical Thinking and Expression
Activity Description
Preparation:
-
Choose an artist of the month
- For example, Vincent Van Gogh
-
Select pictures by the artist and choose one piece to focus on
- You may wish to create a slide show or find large posters
-
Select a story to read aloud to the class that refers to the artist of the month
- For example: Camille and the Sunflower-A Story About Vincent Van Gogh, by Laurence Anholt
- Preview the story and note places to stop for brief discussions
- Gather and set up paint materials at an art center or in student groups
Implementation:
Session 1:
- Introduce your artist of the month and read a story about him or her to provide background knowledge
- Invite students to view some of the artist’s work
-
Focus on one particular piece of artwork, using the Visual Thinking Strategies questions to support critical thinking
- Ask “What do you see?”
- Encourage students to point out specific details from the picture
- Encourage students to support their ideas by asking “What makes you say that?”
- Move the discussion along by saying “What more can you find?”
- Introduce the task of creating individual interpretations of the selected artwork
- Distribute materials and invite students to begin painting
-
Post picture of selected work of art at the front of the classroom for students to refer to while working independently
- Encourage students to use the posted artwork as a guide for their individual interpretation so that they understand that their artwork may look slightly different from the artist’s work as well as their classmates
Session 2:
- Explain to students that they will write a paragraph giving their opinion on for whom they think the artist created this work of art
-
Work with students to brainstorm sentence starters to begin their main point and supporting evidence
- Divide a piece of chart paper in half and write: “For whom did this artist create this work of art?” and “ What makes you say that?” as headings for each column
- Brainstorm sentence starters for each question and record their ideas with a different color. For example: I think that... In my opinion... Perhaps the artist painted this picture for..., I think this because in the text it said... I know this because in the picture I noticed...”
- Ask students to share ideas for completing each sentence
-
Write headings Main Idea and Supporting Evidence on another piece of chart paper
- Discuss and brainstorm 2-3 requirements for each heading and record idea. For example: Main Idea Requirement-States the person for whom the artist created this work of art
- Model a paragraph and post it for students to refer to
-
Have students complete written paragraphs
- Encourage students to refer to chart for sentence starters, exemplar and paragraph requirements
Adaptations For
English Language Learners/ESL:
- Prior to whole class discussion provide sentence starters to students and allow time to practice speaking aloud
LD/Reading & Writing Difficulties:
- Provide an individual copy of sentence starters when writing the paragraph
- Allow paragraph to be written using a typing program or speech-to-text software program
- Scribe written paragraph for student so that the student's ideas are the focus
Cultural Appropriateness & Diversity:
- Select artists each month from a variety of cultures
Differentiated Instruction:
- Encourage varied responses during discussion of artwork
- Provide a variety of sentence starters as examples from which students can choose
Related References
Evidence: Danko-McGhee, K. (2007). Floating experiences: Empowering early childhood educators to encourage critical thinking in young children through the visual arts. Art Education, 60, 13-16.
Activity Objective
The goal of Thinking Strategies: Exploring Artwork to Enhance Critical Thinking and Expression is to use a method developed by Abigail Housen and Philip Yenawine to build students' inquiry skills and their ability to make inferences orally and in writing.
What You Need
Prep Time:
20-30 minutes - Choose an artist of the month
- Gather examples of the artist's work
- Select a story that refers to artist
- Gather and set up paint materials
Task Time:
2, 40 minute sessions Session 1:
- Teacher introduces an artist and his or her work
- Teacher presents pictures of art and helps students think critically about it by asking "What do you see? What makes you say that?"
- Students create own interpretation of selected artwork
Session 2:
- Students create prompts to support paragraph writing about who the work was created for
- Students write paragraph
Materials Required:
Teacher:
- Selected works by a chosen artist
- Story about the artist
- Chart paper
- Markers
Students:
- Paints
- Paintbrushes
- Painting paper
- Lined paper
- Pencils
What You Do
Teacher Role:
Facilitator:
- when teacher presents posters and during discussion
Modeling:
- when going through the steps of writing a paragraph
Supporter:
- when students create their own artwork and write their paragraph
Student Grouping:
Whole class:
- during teacher presentation, student discussion, read aloud and teacher modeling of how to write a paragraph
Individual:
- when students create artwork and write paragraph
Assessment Ideas:
- Use a checklist during the whole class discussion as a way to track participation and speaking and listening skills
- Create an individual requirements list that reflects the written paragraph chart and use this to assess students' responses to questions
Quick Tips
Activity Extensions:
- Create an artist of the month center with books, pictures and other art-related materials
- Have students select an artist of interest from a list of artists, research that artist and create their own interpretation of artwork by selected artist
- Present student artwork and written paragraphs during an art gallery and invite other classes and family members to view work
- Have students research an artist and write a biography of selected artist
- Have students create their own story of an artist and present the story in the form of a picture book or comic
- In small groups have students view a given poster or picture of an artists, discuss the artwork following the same format as above and present their findings to the class
Additional Comments:
- The Visual Thinking Strategies method should promote participation and encourage students to take risks. Facilitate the discussion by continuously referring to the open-ended questions "What do you see?" and "What makes you say that?" rather than leading the students to a correct response.
- Encourage students to think outside of the box. Although they are creating a work of art based on a given artwork, creativity should be promoted.
- Guide students during their written work by encouraging them to always go back to the text or picture to look for evidence to support their thinking.
Other Adaptations/Modifications:
- Provide a quiet working space for students disturbed by sound
- Have the story available on a computer software reading program for additional listening