Writing Assessment Tools
Assessing Students' Writing At All Stages of the Writing Process (Virtual Tour)
Activity Description
Preparation:
-
Prepare writing cards for informal assessment
- For example, have students describe what is happening in a picture or respond to a sentence starter
-
Prepare student tracking sheets
- Record the student's name at the top of a lined paper
- Record the name of the assessment and date of completion
- Include columns for observations
-
Select a formal assessment tool
-
For instance, use the K-8 Continuum for Assessing Narrative Writing
- This continuum is especially useful to use in correspondence with Lucy Calkins' Writing Workshop Program
-
For instance, use the K-8 Continuum for Assessing Narrative Writing
Implementation:
Informal Writing Assessment:
-
Introduce a writing task
- Give students specific guidelines for completion (e.g., try to write 5 sentences in the next 10 minutes)
-
Have students write a goal or favorite activity
- Students may share a school-related goal or a goal related to an activity outside of school
- You may wish to record the students' ideas on a chart paper
-
Have students complete the writing task
- Ensure that all students understand the task by observing and checking in with each student
- Make sure to include the date directly on the piece of writing
- Meet one-on-one with each student to discuss the writing task, particularly if the writing relates to students' goals
- Collect the writing samples
-
Record your observations on a student tracking sheet
- For instance, record words or letters that are written in reverse, record use of or lack of punctuation marks, record legibility
- Record next steps for each student
- Complete steps 1-6 at multiple time points throughout the year
Formal Writing Assessment:
-
Introduce a writing task
- For example, tell students about your favorite outdoor activity
-
Model the writing task
-
Record 3-5 ideas related to the writing task on a piece of chart paper
- Think aloud about the writing process as you record your ideas
-
Record 3-5 ideas related to the writing task on a piece of chart paper
-
Have students complete the writing task
- For example, have students write a short paragraph about their favorite outdoor activity
- Collect the students’ writing
- Use a rubric or standardized assessment chart to assess each student’s writing
-
For instance, use the K-8 Continuum for Assessing Narrative Writing
- This continuum is especially useful to use in correspondence with Lucy Calkins' Writing Workshop Program
-
Record each student’s level on a student tracking sheet
-
You may also wish to record observations of students' writing
- For instance, record words or letters that are written in reverse
-
You may also wish to record observations of students' writing
-
Meet with each student to discuss his/her piece of writing
- Discuss the student's strengths, next steps and goals
- Complete steps 1-8 at multiple time points throughout the year
Adaptations For
English Language Learners/ESL:
- Use short and simple instructions - Repeat instructions - Pause often during each assessment
LD/Reading & Writing Difficulties:
- Use short and simple instructions - Repeat instructions - Administer short writing tasks and provide extra time
Cultural Appropriateness & Diversity:
- Select writing tasks that represent all backgrounds, genders, exceptionalities and avoid stereotypes
Differentiated Instruction:
- Have students repeat instructions - Model each assessment response - Close proximity to students
Related References
Additional Links:
Units of Study for Primary Writing: A Year Long Curriculum: http://www.unitsofstudy.com/default.asp
The Reading & Writing Project, Writing Assessments: http://readingandwritingproject.com/resources/assessments/writing-assessments.html
K-8 Continuum for Assessing Narrative Writing: http://www.tc.columbia.edu/rwp/CANW_8_12.pdf
Evidence:
Romeo, L. (2008). Informal writing assessment linked to instruction: A continuous process for teachers, students, and parents. Reading & Writing Quarterly, 24(1), 25-51.
Activity Objective
The goal of Writing Assessment Tools: Assessing Students' Writing At All Stages of the Writing Process (Virtual Tour) is to use informal and formal assessments to assess students' writing at all stages of the writing process.
What You Need
Prep Time:
10 minutes
- Prepare writing task
- Prepare student tracking sheets
- Select formal assessment tool
Task Time:
2, 30-minute sessions Informal Writing Assessment:
- Teacher introduces writing task
- Students write short response
- Students discuss response with teacher
- Teacher records observations
Formal Writing Assessment:
- Teacher introduces writing task
- Students complete task
- Teacher uses formal tool to assess writing
- Students and teacher meet for a writing conference
Materials Required:
Teacher:
- Chart paper
- Markers
Students:
- Construction paper
- Lined paper
- Pencil
What You Do
Teacher Role:
Direct instruction:
- while teacher introduces and models writing task
Facilitator:
- while students complete writing task
Consultant:
- while student and teacher conference
Student Grouping:
Whole class:
- during introduction of task
Individual:
- during completion of task and writing conference
Assessment Ideas:
- Track students' progress throughout the year by recording observations on a student tracking sheet
Quick Tips
Additional Comments:
- Weekly informal assessments are a quick and efficient way to monitor struggling students.
- Keep writing assessments short to avoid feelings of frustration especially for struggling writers.
- Keep a record of the writing conferences you hold with each student.
- Check in with students on a regular basis to ensure that each student understands his/her writing goals and steps towards these goals.
- Track student-teacher conferences in a chart and use this chart as a formative assessment piece to guide and plan writing lessons and tasks.
- Speech-to-text software can be used when assessing writing elements like, ideas and word choice.
- Provide graphic organizers used in lessons to help students who struggle with idea generation and organization.
Other Adaptations/Modifications:
- Strategically seat students who might require cues to refocus
- Provide a quiet working space for students disturbed by sound
- Assistive technology provides students with independence